Report
Writing - Doing It Better to Better Your Business
By: Alan Carson, Carson Dunlop
November 2005
Introduction
We all like inspecting houses. It’s fun and challenging and we are really
good at seeing things that mere mortals can’t. The “show and tell” with
clients is rewarding, and the appreciation they feel at the end of the process
gives us real job satisfaction. But,
let’s be honest; most of us don’t
get the same high from writing reports. Why is that? Well,
there are several reasons: Most of us are not trained and experienced as technical writers, so although
we know lots more about houses than our clients, we may not know more about
writing.
Most people spent much more time communicating verbally than in writing,
so it’s only natural that we are better at speaking. Writing is more work
because it doesn’t come as naturally.
Writing is a more challenging medium because it does not include tools like
tone of voice, volume, speed and tempo, hand gestures, body language, and the
immediate feedback provided when speaking face to face.
Writing inspection reports is hard because we have to take complex technical
issues and make them easy to understand.
Because the report is the permanent record, writing it is more intimidating
than inspecting. When writing a report, you don’t get the feedback
that allows you to clarify or reword an explanation. You get one chance
to get it
right.
It is hard to remember everything that was discussed at the inspection. Most
of us have left something out of an inspection report at least once. Our memories
and handwritten notes can be imperfect. The fear of omission adds stress to
the report writing process.
Another difficulty is the selection process. What do you tell clients and what
do you leave out? If you documented all of the thought processes and decisions
you made during the inspection, the report would be very long indeed. And if
you included every word you said to your client, the report would be enormous.
The filtering process creates anxiety because leaving something out creates
a risk of being sued. On the other hand, putting in something you did not discuss
on site creates a different sort of risk - a very unhappy client.
And did we mention that the English language is a particularly difficult one
to use? There are a myriad of rules and almost as many exceptions to those
rules.
These issues have been carefully researched and developed since 1978 along
with our overall definition of a home inspection, based on doing thousands
of reports every year. We have worked hard to come up with a definition of
home inspection that includes appropriate reference to the report writing process.
The definition is as follows: A business with illogically high liability, slim profit margins and limited
economies of scale. An incredibly diverse, multi-disciplined consulting service,
delivered under difficult in-field circumstances, before a hostile audience
in an impossibly short time frame, requiring the production of an extraordinarily
detailed technical report, almost instantly, without benefit of research facilities
or resources.
To sum it up, writing a report is a challenging process that provides
an excellent opportunity to look foolish and to get sued. But we have to
do it to help our
clients (since they’ll only remember 10 to 15% of what was said), to
meet inspection standards or licensing requirements, and to compete in the
market place. So, how do we minimize the pain and maximize the gain? Let’s
start by looking at what we are trying to accomplish, and move on to some ways
to succeed. We’ll discuss report writing in general, and touch on
various report formats. What Are We Trying To Accomplish?
- Help clients make an important buying decision
- Make it easy for clients to address the defects after they settle in
- Reduce our chances of being sued successfully
- Satisfy association requirements
- Market our business – differentiate ourselves with an outstanding
report
What Do Clients Want In An Inspection Report?
Based on tens of thousands of inspections, we have learned what our clients
are looking for.
-
Clarity – everything should be relevant, and there should be no extra
words
- Sound advice and no surprises
- Brevity - pictures are worth 1,000 words
- The ability to make the right decision in the shortest time
What Would We Want When Reading To Make A Decision?
We put ourselves in our clients’ shoes and came up with this list
of what we would want.
-
A short executive summary
- Clear, simple communication
- Give me the important stuff first - newspaper articles deliver all the
key facts in the first paragraph.
- Allow me, but don’t force me, to drill down to get in-depth information
where I choose
- No jargon or tech terms without translation
- Navigation tools that let me know where I am and let me move anywhere easily
- What Do You Want When Writing Reports?
We have asked hundreds of inspectors what they are looking for. These are the
top answers we have received.
Fast, because time is money
Easy to say what I want – flexibility
A finished product I will be proud of
Easy to move around quickly so I can work system-by-system or room-by-room
Easy to see what I have and have not done
A reminder system if I forget something
A search tool to help me quickly find what I need
Templates for typical homes, systems or problems that I can set myself
No double entry of inspection data, client data, inspection address, fee etc.
What Would The Ideal Report Look Like?
1. From the home inspector’s perspective -
If we could write what we wanted, it might look something like this: Dear Client, What
I told you on site was pretty much it, but we don’t guarantee anything.
The big item is the roof, and there are a bunch of little things. Get specialists
to check every part of the house, especially the roof, before you take possession
of the home. And remember, houses aren’t perfect so there will be
problems that come up. Your Inspector We’re
not sure clients would like this. 2.
From the homebuyer’s perspective -
If they could get what we wanted, it might look something like this:
For every single house component -
This item is working perfectly now under all conditions, will need a repair
costing $250 in 2 ½ years and then will last another 3 ¾ years,
and cost $765 to replace. Here is the phone number of someone who will
fix or replace it, and give you a discount as well as a lifetime warranty. And
they’d like a summary at the beginning that lists in chronological
order everything they’ll have to do in the home with dates and costs. What is useful information?
So, we’re pretty sure we can’t write the reports we want or the
reports clients want. Life is full of compromises isn’t it? So what can
we do? Well, We can meet them in the middle. We can take responsibility for
our work, within our scope of work. It’s fine to make it clear that we
don’t go beyond our scope. It’s also important for our business
success that we provide useful information to clients on issues within
our expertise. How would you define useful information?
•
A brief description to define the system or component • Identify non-performing
items or items that will fail soon, noting their location. • The implication
of the defect to the home owner • Direction as to what should be done
about it and when • In some markets, we may also provide ballpark
repair costs If this all sounds trivial,
let’s spend a moment talking about reports
that provide little or no useful information. For example -
“
The swimming pool is located in the back yard.” (I knew that already!) “The
2 inch by 8 inch joists are spaced 16 inches apart and support diagonal plank
subflooring.” (So what? Is that good or bad?) “The stairwell lighting
is controlled by 3-way switches.” (Is that a problem?) “An overflow
was noted on the kitchen sink.” (That’s good, right?) The furnace
capacity is 80,000 BTU/hr. (and…….?) In
the first statement, the client picks up no valuable information. In
the rest, there is not enough information for the client to know if
there is
a problem, let alone whether it is a serious, expensive, safety or priority
item.
When we don’t answer the “So what?” question for clients,
we aren’t doing our job. Stop Guessing And Start Asking
So far in this article, we have given you our perspective based on
our experience and beliefs. Is that authoritative? Maybe, because
we’ve been in
the home inspection business since 1978, have worked with many reporting
systems
- electronic and paper, trained and spoken to many, many inspectors,
and written some pretty comprehensive training materials. But is that
enough?
Some would say no, especially in a customer-centric business model. There
is a rule of customer service that says, “Give the customer what
they want, the way they want it.” Every home inspector has an opinion
as to what customers want, but few have asked. And some would say that customers
don’t know what they should want. But while we spend a lot of time
adjusting client expectations to fit the limitations of a home inspection,
we spend very
little time adjusting our service to fit what clients want. We at Carson Dunlop have certainly been guilty of this, until we discovered
an easy and inexpensive way to survey our customers and ask them what they
wanted in an inspection report. We surveyed recent home inspection customers
and received 350 responses. The percents below indicate the number who agreed
or strongly agreed with the following statements: 96% - Reports should include a short executive summary.
• 81% - Point form is easier for me to read than paragraph style.
• 88% - Reports should be short and to the point, but provide easy access
to reference material if I need more information.
• 98% - Headings should be used to help me stay oriented while reading.
• 44% - Reports should include codes and legends to save space. A directory
to look up what the codes mean should be available somewhere in the report.
• 99% - Reports should make it clear why something is an issue.
• 97% - Reports should tell me what to do about the issues that the inspector
identified.
• 98% - Reports should prioritize issues for me.
92% - Illustrations would helpful if they are clear and relevant.
• 87% - Photos of issues in the home would be helpful in the report
• 93% - Reports should include ballpark costs to correct problems.
• 77% - The comprehensive report can be delivered within 24 hours after
the inspection as long as I have a verbal/printed summary that gives me the big
picture at
the end of the inspection. We may decide
to respond to some or all of these, but at least we now know what clients
are looking for. We’ll spend the rest of the paper addressing
some of the key report writing questions, and close with what we think
are some key tips for successful report writing. Report Formats - Electronic Or Paper?
People regularly debate the benefits of electronic and paper-based
reporting systems. We break the discussion into two components
- input and output.
Let’s look at the input side first. Input - Electronic or paper
• Paper can be faster
•
Electronic can simulate paper – checklists, for example
• Electronic can store more selections more efficiently
• Electronic can be more convenient - PDA vs. clipboard
• Electronic can capture input for processing and storage
• Electronic input can be converted into output
• Paper can also act as output, but does not convert readily or store efficiently Now
let’s look at report outputs. Output - Electronic or paper
• Information can be layered more easily with electronic formats (for example,
hyperlinks can be embedded into reports.)
• Color is much cheaper to use with electronic reports than with paper
• Electronic output is easier to send to multiple recipients
• Navigation inside an electronic document can be easier
• Storage is cheaper and more space efficient with electronic reports
• Storage is easier to duplicate for back-up
• Some electronic output can be used for data analysis
• Paper can be cheaper
• Electronic can be cheaper, if there is no hard copy
• Where output is handwritten, legibility can be an issue Clearly there are pros and cons to each. A recent survey showed almost 80%
of inspectors use electronic reporting systems. Our conclusion is that electronic
reports offer some advantages over paper-based reports, but we understand that
paper works best for some people. Many systems can also provide both electronic
and paper outputs. Make Or Buy?
Home inspectors can create their own report systems or purchase or subscribe
to one of the many systems available in the market. There are several considerations
in this decision: Are you a skilled technical writer?
Do you have the time to create something from scratch?
Is your time better spent building this or building your business?
Do you have the technology skills and budget to create better product than
is already available?
Do you have the time and energy to keep the system up to date over the long
term?
In our opinion, report writing systems have improved significantly over the
years and it would take a talented and dedicated home inspector a great deal
of time to build a better mousetrap. We think it makes sense to look at the
reporting systems available, to see if there is one that will suit your needs. Building The Knowledge Base
Whether you make or buy your reporting system, you will need some sort of knowledge
base. Many reporting systems have thousands of standard comments. These comments
cover such areas as defects, descriptions, general maintenance advice, implications,
limitations of problems, and mini-technical articles. Some also have authoritative technical reference articles in addition to the
standard database comments. The ability to direct clients to additional resource
material with no research, writing, drawing, or sorting is a tremendous benefit.
This helps establish your credibility as the home expert, without spending
years building the library. If you are considering building your own system, determine whether you want
to be able to offer this added information, and consider the time and research
required to create it. How Much Information Is Enough?
Some inspectors provide a lot of detail about issues; others do not.
Why would there be different approaches? One of the challenges
in home inspection
is
that we don’t know how much clients know. Worse still, clients
are problematic because many know a lot about some things and little
about others. And, some clients want
to know a lot, and others don’t. Some don’t
want to know much when they buy the house. “Just give me the Bottom Line.” But
then they want all kinds of detail when they move into the house. “What
did you say we should do about that torn valley flashing? When? Where?
Why?” So how can we write a report that will satisfy everyone? We think there is
a solution -
The report written in layers;
1. The first is an executive summary or bottom line.
2. The second layer is a report that tells people about issues and what to
do about them.
3. The third layer is the detailed reference material that allows people
to drill down and get more data. People don’t have to read long narratives
on issues they are not interested in, but can do so easily if they want. The layering approach works with both paper and electronic reports, and can
be particularly elegant in an electronic report. Remember how we talked about
giving people what they want the way they want it? Include A Summary?
Summaries offer significant advantages for clients and we know that clients
want them, because we asked. The argument against summaries is that our liability
is increased because people will rely on the summary and not read the entire
report. We are comfortable that we can provide wording in the summary to
make it clear to any reasonable person that, The summary is provided as a
courtesy and is not a substitute for the entire report. The complete report
must be read and considered before making decisions related to the home inspection. Summaries
are easy to build with most electronic reporting software, taking
almost no time or effort. They can also include other valuable comments
such as these: “All conditions noted in the report should be further investigated
by a qualified specialist for related or additional conditions.” Some
would add, “…PRIOR to the close of escrow.” Reporting On Site
Some inspectors deliver their final report on site. Others deliver it later,
usually within 24 hours. The split among inspectors is about 50/50. We think
either option is fine, as long as clients have enough information at the
end of the inspection to make their critical buying decision, and as long
as the client receives the final report within 24 hours. We
said earlier that clients behave differently at different times.
When they are trying to decide whether to buy the home, they need
to know just the
Bottom Line, focusing on the significant items. After they move in, they want
to know
chapter and verse, so they can look after the home. That’s when they
get into the body of the report in detail. How Can A Reporting System Reduce My Liability?
We think there are several ways:
• Define your scope of work clearly so that client expectations are appropriate.
Your contract should contain this and should be delivered with and referenced
in the report.
•
Stay within your scope of work. Don’t add commentary on excluded
items or people will assume there is nothing you really exclude.
• Use simple language.
• Use spell check to help you say what you mean.
• Include illustrations to help you be clear.
•
Structure the report to help you include everything you need. (Set up and check
for items you can’t afford to miss.)
• Use a reporting system that calls for consistency. For every defect,
you should have o The item
o The problem
o The implication
o The location
o The recommended action
o The time frame
We look to minimize risk, without compromising customer service. Good systems
help you accomplish these goals. Is My Report A Marketing Tool?
We think it should be. It should create a positive image of your company
and you should assume your report will be shared with others – friends
and family, real estate sales professionals, lawyers, lenders, insurers
and so on. It would be a wasted opportunity not to make your company look
really
good every chance you get. Imagine
the leverage you create when people read your report and say, “Wow
that was easier than I thought it was going to be. I really understand my house
now. Thank you!” or, “That was the best technical report I
have ever read, on any subject! It was clear, easy to read and easy to
understand.” We should be clear; a great reporting system will not save a bad home inspection
or a bad home inspector, but it can make a good one look great. What Should Reports Cost?
Over the years a number of surveys have indicated that inspectors consistently
spend an average of roughly 4 to 4.5% of their sales on report writing. If
your fee is $300, that is $12.00 to $13.20 per report. You can spend almost
nothing on reports or more than $40 per report. The
hard cost of the report is not the only factor to consider. Let’s
look at some of the soft or hidden costs of report writing. If you spend 1½ to
2 hours writing every report, and you could use a system that would cut that
time by ½ hour, what would that be worth? Well, if you do 300 inspections
a year, that’s 150 hours, or 4 working weeks! If you do two inspections
a day, you’ll save (20 days x 2 inspections/day x $300/inspection) $12,000
in lost opportunity! And if you could save a full hour per report, you’ll
save 300 hours (8 weeks) or $24,000! >Some
systems allow you to book inspections electronically, and the client
data moves automatically into your reports. The savings in time and reduced
transcription mistakes are certainly worth something. Some report writing
software makes it very easy to email confirmations to clients and agents. This
improved
communication reduces confusion and missed appointments, saving time and
money. Some systems help track your receivables, so you can contact people who owe
you money. Some also help you track your sales, and see how your business is
growing and where it comes from. There are even reporting systems that archive
your records for you, so you have no storage or retrieval costs, and more importantly,
you can always find an old report instantly when you need it. One of the other soft costs is how much time you spend customizing and updating
your reporting system. Some of the new web-based systems are updated automatically
for you, minimizing time spent keeping current, and reducing mistakes made
because your system is not up to date. A Peek Into The Future
Looking ahead, software will move onto the web and away from the conventional
installed packages we are used to seeing. The benefits are clear:
• Zero installation
• Platform independence
• Anywhere/anytime access
• Continuous improvement
Microsoft is going there with Windows and Office. Google and several others
there are already there. We will see more software services that we’ll
subscribe to rather than buying software. A new degree of richness and
flexibility is emerging on the web. Our Top 10 (or so) Report Writing Tips
Irrespective of what reporting tool you use, here are some key suggestions
to help make your reports effective for clients and protective for you. Don’t
use technical jargon without an explanation or illustration. Header,
joist, truss, swale, conductor, heat exchanger and polarity are all examples
of words that without further description mean very little to most people.
We recommend against using Satisfactory, Acceptable, Adequate, Functional,
etc. In many situations, you won’t know whether is something is satisfactory
under all conditions. (And just for the record, most home inspection Errors
and Omissions Insurance experts hate those terms, since they cause problems
for inspectors and their insurers.) Many defects only show up under certain
scenarios. Bathtub enclosures may not leak until someone stands in the shower,
deflecting water against the walls. It’s better to remain silent where
no defects were noted, or if you are compelled to comment on every item you
inspect, say something like, “No defects were observed during the
inspection.”
Don’t guess. If you don’t know, find out, find someone who
knows or recommend that the client find out.
Don’t leap to conclusions. Report what you see, and if you are going
to speculate about the cause or effect, say so. “We noted extensive
water damage at the eaves and exterior siding. While it could not be verified,
there
may be concealed damage to the underlying structure.”
Be definitive if you know, and clear about why you can’t be definitive
when needed. “We could not determine whether there is damage behind the
wall, because there is no access to this area.” Use the words possible
and suspected sparingly.
Set a limit as to how often you recommend further evaluation by a specialist
in a report. If you use it on 50% of the issues you identify, readers will
see a pattern and may question your competence.
Use industry standards to set your scope of work. Instead of saying, “We
don’t test the alarm system”. say, “A professional home
inspection does not include a test of the alarm system.”
Record job-specific limitations factually and clearly in a separate section
of the report. Don’t mix limitations, defects, descriptions and maintenance
tips together.
Be consistent. Don’t go into great depth on a single topic just because
you know more about it. Clients and judges won’t understand why you didn’t
go to the same depth on every area of the home.
Check your spelling. Clients may assume that if your English is sloppy, so
was your inspection.
Write what you say, and say what you write. There is a temptation to go easy
when describing a problem on site, especially if there is a seller and a real
estate agent nearby. There is also a temptation to come down hard in the report
to protect yourself. This frustrates everyone, is poor customer service and
is bad for your business.
Include implications. Don’t make the client ask, “So what?”
Stay away from code references. No one knows all codes. Codes have varying
effective dates. You will be considered a code inspector and will attract
additional liability. Simply describe the condition and the implication. “The
short railing is dangerous because it will not prevent people from falling
off the
balcony.”
Summary
So, reports are a necessary evil that are not going away any time soon.
The goal is to find a way to write reports quickly that will delight customers
while protecting yourself. The better the system, the more easily you will
be able to meet this goal. After 27 years’ experience, asking lots
of customers and lots of home inspectors, and after making most of the
mistakes
possible, we have finally found a reporting solution that allows us to
achieve all of these goals. Alan Carson is a Past President of ASHI, a principal in Carson Dunlop, authors
of the Home Reference Book, the ASHI@HOME training program, the Illustrated
Home, and most recently, HORIZON a unique web based reporting system. See www.discoverhorizon.com
for more information. You can reach Alan directly at carson@carsondunlop.com or 416-964-9415.
<< Back to Articles
|